BayBuzz

Menu

Andrew Frame – Get Real

BayBuzz13 November 2008

Napier in the 80’s was a wonderful place to grow up. It was safe, friendly, innovative and interesting.

While virtually all my generation went off to explore the corners of the globe, I never left. Why would I want to live anywhere else? The climate is gorgeous, the people are fantastic, and you’re four hours drive from pretty well anywhere in the North Island. Whenever I drive out to Bay View and look across at Napier, or see the hill lit up at night coming along the expressway or Clive, I fall in love with the city all over again. Even the bone-chilling westerly that rips down Emerson Street in the middle of winter has a special place in my heart (albeit small and remote).

Remaining when the others left can be considered both a blessing and a burden. While I have yet to embark on my grand tour of the world and experience all its diversities, I have been able to watch the city I love grow. Though at times, I wonder why I stayed.

As Napier’s popularity grew over the past decades, the promotion of our great region followed at a much-retarded rate. Growing up, the only time Hawke’s Bay featured nationally was either following a natural disaster or as an unrecognisable person (officially monikered as “a friend from the Hawke’s Bay”) making a drunken fool of themselves in Metro magazine.

While Generation X and Y’ers became alienated, cynical, experimental and savvy, the promotion of our province hit a large speed bump at wine and Art Deco, lost several wheels and retired.

It could just be that I’m just an occasional beer man but, to me, calling Hawke’s Bay “Wine Country” makes us sound like a region of pompous drunks.

Vineyards may indeed surround us and provide a portion of the region’s income, but as a branding tool, “Wine Country” has been done to death. Recently I saw it used as branding for a heavy industrial business, which tipped it over the edge for me. “I’ll have the 400hp, 5000rpm drilling rig and a bottle of Sav’?” Yeah, right!

Art Deco is a huge money-spinner for Napier. In the 80’s there was no such thing, the decorative facades painted or boarded over and ignored. The movement only started when new banks were built on opposite corners of the Emerson & Hastings Streets intersection. This involved destroying their architecturally gorgeous predecessors. The resulting outrage created the Art Deco Trust to protect the remaining buildings. Most of Napier’s CBD buildings (Emerson St in particular) didn’t receive makeovers until well into the 90’s, when the current paved mall was established. The city is more attractive for the revival, but it’s not just the buildings that make a city.

Art Deco Weekend is a mixed bag. For accommodation providers and restauranteurs – fantastic! – as all the visitors need somewhere to eat and crash for the night after soiréeing their little faux furs off.

Speak to virtually any other retailer, and they will wonder why they stayed open.

I doubt many people who take part in its feature event, the “Great Gatsby Picnic,” have read the book it takes its title from. While considered an American classic, the story reads like TV series “Dallas” meets a Serious Fraud Office investigation. “Wine Country’s” natural grape aquifers run near dry, yet there is barely a police breath-check post, or public alcohol ban within grapeshot.

The “Depression Dinner” is even worse, as people pay to eat like a pauper for the evening (once again alcohol, somehow, included). Life must be so hard. The weekend can feel insultingly bourgeois.

As does our city’s mascot, Bertie Wooster. P.G. Wodehouse’s farcical little dandy. Could our promoters have thought of a more shallow mascot for this fine city? Was his butler, Geeves, too smart, too servile, or was Paris Hilton just not available?

The creation of “Deco Decanted”, the summer event’s mid-winter cousin, acts as proof of the city’s complete lack of original promotion or thought.

What will happen to Napier’s tourism when Art Deco Weekend eventually appears in the “Uncool” section of Metro magazine or the Weekend Herald that all the “friends from Hawke’s Bay” aspire to? Or the money falls out the bottom of the wine vat?

But enough wingeing. If I were head of Napier City Marketing, this is what I’d do:

Stop trying to recreate Ponsonby or Paris in our inner city. Our greatest asset is our region and people. We can have similarities to those places, but we are Napier, we are unique.

Use the Soundshell! With its wide-open space, proximity to the heart of town and such a  beautiful vista, why is it such a waste? Imagine a month of summer evening concerts there with the moon rising out of the sea. It would be fantastic!

And while we’re at it, keep town open later on summer evenings. This is a double-edged sword. People aren’t in town, because nothing is open. And nothing is open, because people aren’t in town. We need trailblazers. A café here, a shop there open later and they will come. Make it a market, music, the more, the merrier. Why just limit it to Art Deco Weekend?

International Day of the Child got handed off to the babysitters to make way for the Great Long Lunch. Sailing regattas, fishing competitions and offshore powerboat racing were all relegated to Ahuriri. Make them city and Hawke Bay-wide events. Share the love and we will all share the benefits.

Have victory parades and parties for our victorious Magpies, Hawks and Rovers where the public can meet their local sporting heroes. Support of local events needs to be far less shallow than it currently is. Especially if we are to secure Napier as a base and venue for the likes of Rugby World Cup teams.

Lastly, include everyone. I’m not a big wine person and my generation really doesn’t care about Art Deco, yet that is all the city pushes.

The biggest question to be asked, though, must be: “Why have none of these things happened yet?”

For the past decade our city’s promotional strategy has been so entrenched and blinkered by its architectural and alcoholic cash cows that we have lost forward momentum. Criticise it or attempt to inject young, new approaches and you are ignored and ostracised. We must expunge these complacencies and the complacent people who protect them, while shunning new ideas.

Is it any wonder all the bright minds go elsewhere out of frustration when the blinkers go on and the goalposts are moved once again?

While you’re here…

… we need to ask your help. We want to keep our journalism as accessible as we can and to highest standard. BayBuzz’s independent reporting – produced locally and focused entirely on Hawke’s Bay – takes a lot of time, hard work – and yes, money.

Many readers who value our reporting help support it with additional contributions. Please consider joining fellow readers who help make BayBuzz more secure and better able to do the job you’ve come to expect.

Your contribution of any size will be deeply appreciated and wisely put to work. Please take a moment to help us. Thank you.

Support BayBuzz

BayBuzz13 November 2008

3 responses to “Andrew Frame – Get Real”

  1. Judith Anderson says:

    Poor Andrew, a muddled mix of love hate and parochial ignorance came pouring out in the above article.

    He has touched lightly on so many issues it's difficult to know what was the most irritating.

    Smug, because he stayed, then critical of the wine industry, (he appears to lack any understanding of how wine and its branding of Hawke's Bay has altered the face of the region.)

    "Innovative" in the 80's – explain please…….

    Oh dear……..thank goodness for those of us who

    chose to come to this wonderful province by choice.

    Has anyone noticed it's the 'outsiders' who are the movers and shakers?

  2. Brian Duggan says:

    You are onto it Andrew, there is a a lack of maturity about the 'tourism' thing and failure to take ownership of the shortcomings of our litle town. Art Deco is the way forward for Napier as a brand and we could embrace the concept with pride. But it is the phoney the bragging the overstated and downright dishonest (at times) promotional strategies that sour the cup. I hope this tiny town can stand up and be proud for what it is and not continue down a 1960's strategy or a 'Napier 30,00 Club' mindset. Local council must get out of business divest and free up the playing field to commercial professionals.

  3. Shane Cameron says:

    Consider yourself 'scathed' Andrew. I'm all in favour of making English a living langauge, my contribution is the scath, a blistering attack about as hot and welcome as a month of Hawkes bay westerlies and carrying about as much hot air and generally scented with orange and chocolate.

    I have actually noticed that the 'movers and shakers' are frequently outsiders, in all sense of the word. And when their world view is infringed upon they generally attack with a scath. They are often ready to proclaim their breadth of vision and even more often "share" it , or impose it.

    One must also wonder why the 'movers and shakers' bothered moving to parochial little old Hawkes bay. It certainly wasn't for the odious little locals they're now neighbours with, with their narrow vision. Maybe they see themselves as modern day white missionaries trying to spread Ponsonby civilisation to the provinces. Well I can tell you, recently we've seen enough of your civilisation, leaky buildings, shonky moneyleaders, maddening congestion and attitudes of undeserved superiority. In fact were I to be pushed I would guess that most movers and shakers came to Hawkes Bay simply because they were small fish in a big pond wherever they were and they saw the chance to cash up whatever little they'd managed to accumulate and move to somewhere cheaper where they could put on airs and graces and forget their past sins.

    …but having said that they do have a sense of humour, who else but a "mover and shaker" could state "He has touched lightly on so many issues it’s difficult to know what was the most irritating," and leave it there. Yes exactly “Oh Dear!” That touched about as lightly as a butterflies footsteps on any of the valid points that Andrew raised.

    Which I guess brings us to the point… Hawkes bay. Wine country, or Whine country? The slightest signs of progress brings out droves of whiners trying to stem any progress that is outside of their narrow "parochial" areas of self interest and aided by the draconian RMA. Anything from a surf reef off west shore (Don't want bloody surfys here) to the urban wilderness that is the old Maori girls school site and the virgin slopes above Ocean beach, all stymied by little people with little thoughts.

    If it's not wine (or Art deco) we don't want it seems to be the catch cry. Well there's an old saying, Ben Franklin i think; something about eggs and baskets. I'm old enough to remember Hawkes bay, the fruit bowl of New Zealand, in fact there's probably at least one of those old signs mouldering beside a road somewhere still. Imagine if we hadn't diversified away from that; meat and wool is the same, the old meat works of Tomoana and Whakatu (employers of thousands in their day) are relics and the woolstores at Pandora are mostly empty. Maybe their demise predates the arrival of the 'movers and shakers' in our bay but they are prime examples that if you stay still you will end up like a dinosaur or a dodo.

    Art deco and the Wine craze have served their purpose, they have put hawkes bay on the map but there must be more to the region, mustn't there? We must diversify, for ourselves and for the tourists that we so desperately clamour for. I watched our mayor on the box last year pushing Art deco ad nauseum and quite frankly was embarrassed. Even the wineries were scarcely mentioned; what's wrong, were they regarded as too Hastings? As a visitor who would visit a region or a city for more than a weekend once in a lifetime for that. Moreover what sort of inbred genetically defeceint sad acts would they find to live in such a poor beknighted area? Surely, if vino and the aftermath of disaster is all we have, or even the best we have why are we still here? Are we that shallow?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cricket Craftsmanship

23 December 2017

I love cricket. I’ve been playing and watching it all my life. With Hawke’s Bay days getting longer and warmer,…

Take Me Home

02 December 2017

For some, the rocketing property boom is a barrier to buying. For others, it’s merely a challenge. We found four…